|
“He’s f-d you good, he’s still f-ing you, and a year from now, you’ll turn around, and he’ll still be back there, f-ing you.”
That’s what the lawyer said after I had explained the financial situation of my company. Or rather, the lack of financial situation. The f-er was Dan Coyne, my business partner. Because he was 30 years older than me, and had been my mentor and friend for 10 years, I had trusted him completely, and the lawyer was having a hard time convincing me that Dan had been pumping up the sales forecast to cover for revenue that was, in reality, rapidly going away.
My company, the Clarinda company, was a typesetting firm that was
making over $10 million a year by doing textbook design, editing, and
layout for publishers like McGraw Hill, Pearson Education, and
Harcourt. We had plants in Iowa, Minnesota, Maryland, New York, and the
Philippines. But we were being squeezed by dirt-cheap competition from
India, and also by the consolidation of our customers, the publishers.
Thomson bought Delmar and then Aspen. Harcourt bought Academic Press
and Mosby, joining them up with previous acquisition Saunders. Then
Thomson and Reed-Elsevier divvied up Harcourt.
Between 1999 and 2003, ten different customers of my company became
two. That consolidation created an “oligopoly.” Unlike a monopoly,
which is capitalism taken to its logical (and disastrous) extreme on
the supply side, an oligopoly is capitalism taken to its extreme by a
limited number of buyers.
I told the lawyer he was wrong. Dan was my friend. He wouldn’t hurt me.
He was, as he had explained many times, “a benevolent capitalist.”
Boy, was I wrong.
I was so wrong, I decided to write a book, Typo, the Last American
Typesetter or How I Made and Lost $4 Million, about what happened to
me, Dan, and the 200 employees of Clarinda when we got squeezed out of
business by market forces beyond our control. The lawyer was right, and
not only did I get my f-ing, so did everyone else, including a lot of
the companies that Clarinda owed money to.
And so it is either delicious irony, cruel fate, or “My Name Is Earl”
karma that just a few months before my book is due to come out, my
publisher, Richard Nash at Soft Skull Press, pulled me aside before our
first meeting with the PR firm to tell me, “I don’t want you to get too
worried, but our distributor, PGW, has just filed bankruptcy.”
What?
PGW is not only the main distributor of over 150 independent
publishers, making it the delicate link between the independent press
and their readers, it is also a distributor of big name authors like
P.J. O’Rourke, Deepak Chopra, Dave Eggers and 4 out of 6 Man Booker
Prize Nominees. PGW is important to publishing in the way bridges are
important to Manhattan, and a couple of years ago they got bought by
Advanced Marketing Services (AMS), who is the bridge for those books to
Amazon, Sam’s Club and so on.

They had become, without anyone noticing, one of a diminishing number
of connections in the buying of all books in the country, or, in other
words, part of an oligopoly. So when I read that the nice folks at
Media Bistro are worried,
“A large portion of the revenues from the publisher's new Dave Eggers
novel, WHAT IS THE WHAT - a percentage of which were to be donated to
the Valentino Achak Deng Foundation to aid the Sudanese in America and
the Sudan -- is now tied up in the bankruptcy. ‘We shipped 60,000
copies during that period and the proceeds are not here yet.’”
I, who have been through this before, think: they are missing the point by several thousand punctuation marks.
There are already proposed buy-out solutions for PGW, but there are
also rumblings of publishers like Simon and Schuster, a unit of Viacom,
trying to get their books out of AMS' warehouse—potentially leading to
a “run on the bank” kind of situation.
This would leave the little guys, the small publishers, the ones who
cannot weather having four months of their receivable cash tied up in
“debtor subordination review,” being, well, I think you know, “f-ed
now, later, and again in a dark alley on their way home.”
So, because an executive at AMS cooked her sales books (she billed
publishers for advertising that was never done, which was already f-ing
them), Dave Eggers won’t make his money to donate and the US public
will find themselves deprived of potentially dozens, hundreds, maybe
thousands, of independent voices.
Doesn’t seem right to me.
Many people seem
to think this is just another bankruptcy story. But it is, in its own
way, possibly bigger than Enron or World Com. Those disasters struck
investors and employees. This catastrophe could silence the small
presses and authors who exposed those and other sins of our times.
When the History channel picked the most important people of the past
1000 years at the turn of the millennium, number one was Johann
Gutenberg, inventor of the printing press. Because without him, the
narrator said, there would never have been a way for the great
scientists, scholars, and promoters of democracy to get their ideas to
the world. And we can’t afford to let what Gutenberg invented by rubbed
out by corporate greed five centuries later.
But then, what can one author do?
Some good links about all this:
Oligopolies in Book Publishing
AMS' doubtful financial history
Some recent info on the bankruptcy from Media Bistro
Amazon suggesting that in this one case, you don't buy from them
My book
|